GENESIS XXXVII:1-XL:23

THE ETERNAL COMBAT BETWEEN LOVE AND HATE

The prophetic vision inspired by the revelation of the divine will is intertwined with the unfolding of events, which, in turn, foretells the inevitability of events. This fact collides with the free will of man, who must walk according to a trajectory traced in advance.

As God foretells Avraham (Abraham) “Your seed and your children’s children will be strangers, unknown in a foreign land where they will be enslaved and oppressed for four hundred years,” this prediction forces a series of events to take place that will lead to Egyptian slavery. Within this scenario, where does free will stand? Perhaps in the quality and specificity of the events, even if they must occur in the anticipated scenario.

The destiny laid out for exile is fulfilled through the central theme of our chapters, which is the jealousy and rivalry relationship between Yosef (Joseph) and his brothers. A relationship that is fueled by Yaakov’s (Jacob’s) excessive love and preference for Yosef to the detriment of his other sons. However, the element that weaves together the succession of events will be dreams: Yosef’s dreams of grandeur, the dreams of the one who served Pharaoh’s cup of wine and his baker and, finally, Pharaoh’s crucial dream.

The biblical text compiles the progressive development of the brotherly relationship. One of the earliest biblical episodes describes the murder of Hevel (Abel) by Kayin (Cain). Then comes the banishment of Yishmael (Ishmael) so that he will not exert a negative influence on his brother Yitschak (Isaac).Followed by Esav’s (Esau’s) rivalry with Yaakov that manifests itself through deception that produces the threat of murder. It culminates in the brothers’ envy and jealousy of Yosef, the firstborn of Rachel, Yaakov’s most beloved wife.

Since by divine decision the development of events must necessarily lead to banishment from the Promised Land, it also serves to highlight psychology and human behavior in circumstances of crisis. Jealousy produces an unfathomable hatred that blinds the person and prevents him from recognizing the enormity of the injustice of his subsequent behavior. Professor Yael Shemesh notes that the Torah (Pentateuch) relates that, after throwing Yosef to certain death in a well, the brothers sit down to eat, indifferent to his pleas and weeping. 

Centuries later, Achashverosh (Ahasuerus) and Haman(Hamman) will also partake of a meal after deciding the death of the Jews through a lottery, as told in the Purim story. As noted, the intensity of hatred is far greater than the depth of love. Many years will pass after having to prostrate themselves before Yosef to obtain food supplies; only then will the feeling of remorse be born of the brothers, who will recognize the great fault they committed against Yosef.

From a certain perspective, the saga of Yosef and his brothers is a moral teaching about retribution: the punishment that ineluctably receives a person for committing an immorality. But there is another lesson: crime does not produce the desired result. Although the “sale” of Yosef makes him disappear from the family scene, Yaakov’s anticipated approach to the brothers does not occur. On the contrary, the father now focuses his feelings on the pain and mourning for the loss of Yosef, he cannot erase it from his memory, because the bearing and “beauty” of this son are directly linked to the memory of his favorite, Rachel. Without being present, Yosef continues to be the favorite son. Despite the favoritism that Yaakovdemonstrates, Yosef is not a figure who, in his younger years, can be easily admired. He is clearly conceited, in love with himself, a young man who informs his father about the weaknesses of his brothers to accentuate the cracks in their characters.

Yosef’s education and the refinement of the temper of his moral fiber demand he moves away from parental protection. He mustgo into exile and learn to fend for himself, to take advantage of his ingenuity to evolve morally. Egypt becomes Yosef’s personal laboratory.

The temptation of Potiphar’s wife  and the internship in Pharaoh’s prisons will serve as an anvil for the blows inflicted on him by fate. Insecurity and danger, uncertainty and unknowns, do not produce the desperation of the spoiled young man. On the contrary, the refined character of his personality that had been sunk in vanity comes to light. Even when he recognizes his brothers, who must prostrate themselves before him and beg for the indispensable sustenance in the years of famine that had struck the entire region, he does not allow the desire for revenge to take hold of his feelings. He understands that events unfolded by God’s will: banishment was necessary for a people to be born, exile from the parental home was necessary so that he, Yosef, could become the royal firstborn, father of two tribes of Israel: Efrayim (Ephraim) and Menashe(Manasseh).